יום רביעי, 14 במרץ 2018

צעצוע אירוויזיוני או משהו אחר ?

נו, אז כבר ראיתם את הקליפ של השיר הישראלי לאירוויזיון 2018? 

מודה.
אישית
במבט ראשון
התחברתי יותר לבריטניה, צרפת, סרביה, דנמרק ואוקראינה
אבל יש להודות - אלה דברים שכבר שמענו שכמותם... 



מה שלא נגיד על השיר הישראלי -
הוא אחר
הוא חדש
אולי מטופש 
אבל יש הרבה אומץ 
במהלך האומנותי הזה 
עם הmada baka (לך תבין מה זה בכלל.... זה מה שהאינטרנט הביא)
וכל הפקה פקה 
האלה 
והביקורת החברתית 
שלא-מסתתרת שם בפנים
אלא מוטחת בפני המאזין/הצופה

וכמובן
יש גם את הנקודה הזו
שאי אפשר להתעלם ממנה -
אי אפשר להישאר אדיש לשיר הזה. 
או שאוהבים אותו או ששונאים אותו. 
אין אמצע.

נטע ברזילי עשתה כאן
אמנות במיטבה. 
לא צריך לטעות כאן. 



יום ראשון, 7 בינואר 2018

The Harry Potter discrepancies : post 1 (covering books 1-4)

The Harry Potter series of books is a favorite of mine and many others. A huge literary phenomena that has many factors behind its success, with Rowling's writing talent first among them, of course.


And still, nothing is perfect. Over the years I've gathered notes of discrepancies I found in the series.

Seeing how people responded to the Big Bang Theory discrepancies post (and its addendum), I've talked around and realized readers would also like a similar critical look at the Harry Potter series of books. As I was just getting the itch to read it again, it seemed like the perfect timing...

Book 1: Harry Potter and the Philosopher's stone (from now on: hp1): 
The book is flaw-less (in my mind) once you realize that Dumbledore is letting harry face challenges intentionally as he prepares him for his (future) final confrontation with Voldemort.

Book 2: Harry Potter and the Chamber of secrets (from now on: hp2): 
Unlike book 1, this one has some discrepancies. Not that many, and yet....

  1. It just cannot be that Lockahrt is as useless as he is described. I mean: the man's books are bestsellers and sensible people such as mrs. Weasley are relying on information gleaned from them that is proven to be effective(consider hp5 and the doxies, p. 96-97). So some of the stuff he authored (or co-authored or stole) is useful. Can't he ever remember any of it at all? Illogical.
  2. Why didn't Ginny take the diary the day after she saw it in harry's hands but instead waited ... and waited... and waited....
  3. How come that Ginny trusted tom's diary again to a measure that let him to take control over her once more ?


Book 3: Harry Potter and the prisoner of azkaban (from now on: hp3):
Most of the book is quite consistent. But as things get more interesting the discrepancies start to add up...

  1. How can it be that the bogart, a shape-shifter, also has all the abilities of those he changes to ? isn't it amazing that a simple creature as that can actually influence harry like a real dementor ?!?
  2. Why didn't Scabbers/Pettigrew run away during the looooong confrontation between the three kids and Black? after all, he fought so decisively to get away from ron as soon as he was found in Hagrid's cabin...
  3. The timing of Snape's entry into the room in the shack (the door moves) and what he says he knows after he reveals himself do not add up.
  4. Why was Harry prepared to kill Sirius Black but objected the killing of Peter Pettigrew?
  5. If Lupin lost his mind each time he became werewolf before the development of the wolfsbane potion, how exactly could his friends control him? after all, neither was larger than him. they could tackle him, but not control him, unless he communicated with him,which implies he kept his mind and consciousness...
  6. How can it be that other than Lupin, no one ever sees Wormtail on the maurauder's map?!? (for example: Snape, Harry, George and Fred (after all, Pettigrew is always in Ron and Harry's dormitory!))
  7. If time-turners are saved in the ministry, how can it be that once Voldemort has influence there, he doesn't get someone to go back in time and tell him that when he goes to kill H.P he must not kill either of the parents?
    after all, all he needs to do in the re-run murder is freeze both parents, and kill only the baby, and nothing shall go wrong.
    (and lets make it clear: Voldemort knew it during book 4 when incredibly illogical efforts were needed and made to support his resurrection; surely getting a time-turner using B. Crouch sr. and sending B. Crouch jr. backwards in time would have been less time consuming and a lot less complicated)
    also see the pottermore article  to realize j.k's confusion in this subject.
  8. When harry confronts Sirius Black he aims a wand at him, intending to kill him.... but Harry never learned a deadly curse... it would only come at book 4...
  9. Dumbledore didn't know about the evolution as animagi of James Potter, Sirius Black and Peter Pettigrew ? did not know of the way that they escorted Remus Lupin during full moon nights? Does that man know anything about things taking place in Hogwarts ?
    [but on the other hand, Dumbledore was told of the prank against Snape, swore Snape to secrecy, and had no other thoughts about the roles that Potter and Black filled in that event? nothing to raise suspicions that justified finding out everything ? [and if he had found it all out, why did he let Black into Hogwarts after 12 years as an escaped prisoner?]]
  10. With time-turners a magical possibility and the greatest wizard of the age believing the story of Black, and knowing that Pettigrew was in Hogwarts at a certain time, are we supposed to believe that there was no possibility to recapture  peter the rat before he could make a significant distance from the area of the lake ?
    no possibility at all ?!?
    this can mean only one option - that Dumbledore sucks as a wizard. Even harry's father & co knew how to make a map that showed everyone's location in Hogwarts. and Dumbledore couldn't go back in time, locate Pettigrew just as he escaped, capture him, introduce him in front of the ministry and save a lot of trouble down the road? do us a favor.


Book 4: Harry Potter and the goblet of fire (from now on: hp4):
As the books grow longer and more complicated, they gather more internal discrepancies, but in JKR's best tradition the rate of accumulation is accelerated as we make progress in the book:

  1. Why have the extreme security measures regarding Sirius Black been removed ? he hasn't been caught. he has shown a proven ability to enter Hogwarts at will. and nobody from the ministry believed his innocence or any other claim made by Harry, Ron and Hermione, right ? so what happened, other than that the Black-storyline is no longer interesting enough ?
  2. They should have used magic... (but they didn't):
    - Ludo Bagman's broken nose
    - Cedric Digory's did not repair his ripped bag
  3. Professor McGonagal couldn't handle Peeves and threatened to inform the principle if he would not stop throwing water bombs.... but in hp3 professor Lupin had no problem handling peeves.
  4. Dobby says he traveled for two whole years trying to find work, but it is November of Harry's fourth year, and Dobby has been released in June of harry's second year, so, I'm getting at no more than a year and a half (rounding up)
  5. Both Cedric and Harry see Krum use an unforgivable curse and yet they continue the tournament? it is an unforgivable curse. a crime that will send Victor to a lifetime in Azkaban. but do they linger to make sure he is caught ? no. they send a help! spark and carry on the competition.
  6. How come, in the priori-incantatem, that harry's father came out before harry's mother?
  7. Why did the Tri-Wizard cup work as a two-way port-key? Harry was supposed to die. What use did it have for Voldemort? after all, he most probably did not plan to go to Hogwarts himself, did he ? and at the beginning of hp4, it was implied that a port-key, once it served its mission, is not active anymore.
  8. So, let us get this straight (this will be a spoiler, if you haven't finished the series): Severus Snape has the dark mark burning, calling him to apparate to his resurrected master. presumably, he goes to Dumbledore, tells him about it. At this moment, they both know that Voldemort is back.
  9. Harry is in the graveyard with V and the joining crowd of death eaters. What do Dumbledore and Snape do in the 15-20 minutes of the ensuing duel in the graveyard, until Harry returns? (Snape makes it clear (hp6, p. 33, talking to Narcissa Malfoy and Bellatrix Lestrange) that he apparated to V two hours after the first call, waiting for Dumbledore's orders).
  10. Why did Fawkes cry a healing tear over Harry's leg, but not over the cut in his hand ?
  11. When minister Fudge entered the room where Barty Crouch jr. was held, he was escorted with a dementor and it applied the kiss to the death eater, why didn't prof. Snape or prof. McGonagall perform a Patronus and saved Barty Crouch jr. ? (we know from hp7 that Snape controls the Patronus spell, and it is safe to assume that so does prof. Mc)
  12. Why didn't Fudge request Harry to take Veritaserum ? why didn't Dumbledore insist ? are there really no ways to check such a thing out ?
  13. The greatest problem with the internal logic of hp4: although the idea of the cup as a port-key is a dramatic ingenuity, it lacks any logical base. whoever set this, could have set any other kind of portkey that would send harry directly to the dark lord. There was no need for the entire year. There was no need for the ongoing risk of B. Crouch jr. being discovered.
    All he had to do was use an opportunity on the first month to entrap harry to touch a magicked portkey. He could have lent Harry a book (remember the one he lent Nevill?)
    True, the complicated way theoretically enabled Harry's capture and death while B. Crouch jr. keeps his position as Moody and is able to get away safely, but we can imagine just as simple ways to achieve the same, once Moody bought Harry's trust (which was as early as after the Malfoy-the-ferret show).
  14. And the last discrepancy for hp4: assuming that the ancient mother sacrifice charm is no longer deterring Voldemort as he now shares Harry's blood, how come that the ancient relations-protection still keeps harry out of harm's way ? 



Just like in real life, going over the first 4 books, it is time to get a breather. We will continue with Harry Potter discrepancies in the next post.

יום רביעי, 27 בדצמבר 2017

The year when it all became real

2017 may be the year when it all became real. When you look at the history of SpaceX's Falcon 9 flights you see that 2017 is a landmark year: the first no-failues year.

When I Watch one of those videos of a launch and landing of a falcon 9  -


I always remember those old science fiction movies. In front of our eyes a science fiction vision is forming into reality.

That vision, thanks to visionary entrepreneur Elon Musk is much broader than just efficiently operating current (and rather un-ambitions, in science fiction terms, space programs). Musk is seriously talking about the making of humanity into a space-crossing civilization. Check out his recent update of the Mars program:


It may take a hundreds of years to actually establish truly independent, self-supporting human settlements on Mars. It might take more.

Think how long it took the American colonies to progress from that first Mayflower voyage to the Declaration of Independence (and the later historical milestones, starting with the Constitutional Convention and going through all those 19th century and 20th century stages which brought it into its current role in human civilization). We might assume that the first Mars colonies will need at least as long a time. So, the minimal scale is 300-400 years from our current time to that future when the Mars united states is a dominant and thriving independent civilization, right ? Maybe. Maybe more. Maybe less. Technology has made some serious changes to the time needed for some changes, right?
Still, It might be that we are closer to a parallel time-frame, that when the Europeans discovered America... Which might make our solar-system futuristic and pessimistic scale into a 500-600 projection.

And yet, the dream of colonizing other planets in our own solar system is just the beginning of the vision. 2017 was also a significant year in the process of discovering earth-like planets outside our own solar system:

This vision might need a 1000 years into the future to be realized. For people born into our own era it may be frustrating, thinking that planets discovered today are going to become targets for actual landing, researching and settling only in another millennia. But to paraphrase the old scientific saying, you can reach this high only if you stand on the shoulders of others. 2017 might be remembered as one of those years when human progress clicked together and created that step in the ladder, leading humanity in the right direction, to a future as a space-going civilization.

יום ראשון, 16 ביולי 2017

The big bang sitcom discrepancies post strikes again

A surprising number of readers wrote about the big bang discrepancies post, and asked to know more about the discrepancies I found in seasons 1 and 2. So, why not deal with those as well?

As I wrote, I avoided including them in the main post, because those seasons were still finding themselves. And yet, as people were curious enough to ask, here as an addendum-style-post, including the most glaring discrepancies of seasons 1 & 2 of the big bang theory sitcom:
It is important to note, however, that I have not included the full list here. Mainly, because it would take pages over pages of tedious details, all summing up to that basic aspect of the series still seeking its shape.

What are the more glaring discrepancies?

  1. s01.e01: sheldon describes as semi-pro in regarding to self-enjoyment, which contradicts, more or less, the rest of the series.
  2. s01.e01: sheldon agrees to sit at another spot instead of his favorite one (this returns again and again).
  3.  s01e03 Leonard tells Sheldon (and not the other way): "I've taken your asthma into account". (as he considers a cat for intimacy). 
  4. s01.e07: Raj speaks near penny. Both are at the same room. He protests Leonard's suggestion that Raj be cut in half, so that a Halo team game would be possible. The full text goes like this: "Leonard: Well the only way we can play teams at this point is if we cut Raj in half.
      Raj: Oh, sure, cut the foreigner in half, there’s a billion more where he came from.
      Penny: Hey, if you guys need a fourth, I’ll play." 
  5. s01e07: The aforementioned lack of a player took place as a result of Howard trying his luck with Christie, a girl from Nebraska that came to California and used penny's hospitality. Howard actually had luck with her, which is quite an unusual event in the history of the sitcom. 
  6. s01e07: Sheldon refers to penny as attractive in the immortal sentence "Okay, that’s it, I don’t know how, but she is cheating. No-one can be that attractive and be this skilled at a video game."
  7. s01e07: Sheldon disagrees to a hypothetical suggestion made by Leonard: to suggest Penny they go dancing with her (as Howard ruins halo night, spending time with Christie). His reply: "assuming we could dance, which we can't". This contradicts s04.e21 where sheldon turns out to be an excelent dancer, due to the qutillion tradition.
  8. s01.e10: Sheldon takes out food thrown to the garbage ?!? (the fact that Sheldon succumbs to Leonard's non-verbal ques and actually throws the take-out food they brought with them is in itself a very non-Sheldonian behavior). 
  9. s01.e11: Sheldon tells of the time he was ill visiting the Heidelberg institute. This story depicts his mother going back to help his father at a crisis at home when he was 15. But later episodes teach us that his father died when he was 14.... (in particular s07e09, the episode that Bernadette's dad and Sheldon bond over Thanksgiving football, remember?).
  10. s02e02: Where is the roommate agreement ? Sheldon evacuates the apartment for a Leonard-Leslie date that was not notified in advance?
  11. s02e02: Sheldon has an arch-enemy (Leslie); but there is no mention of the list !
  12. s02e15: Leonard'd mother tells Sheldon that she and her husband had sex only for reproduction; But a season later, on s03e11, she complains to Penny that she has been responsible for her own orgasms since 1982; how come the sudden appearance of a sex drive and sex interest ?
  13. s02e12 Sheldon does not know how to open a toolbox (or modify a robot). But only 3 chapters earlier, on s02e09, he told Dr. Stephanie Barnett how he built a CAT scanner and was briefly able to see the inside of his sister’s guinea pig, Snowball, before he caught fire. Also compare this to s03e09 where Sheldon he avenges Barry Kripke using sensors and an Apparatus that combines and spills chemical materials... (the memorable "The Vengeance Formulation" foamy vengeance).
  14. s02e15: A tearful Penny tells Dr. Beverly Hofstadter, Leonard's mother, that she was no longer "Slugger" to her father, after she got her first training bra. But on s09e03 and s10e1, Wyatt, Penny's father, addresses her by the nickname. 
Before we depart, two factual anecdotes mentioned once, never repeated, and quite out of character:

  • s01e02: penny rebuilt a tractor engine when she was 12.
  • s01e01: sheldon was sent to boarding shcool (would his loving mother do this to him? not to mention that this does not fit to all other pieces of the Sheldonian childhood puzzle)

And for departure, let us take a trip down memory lane, and recall how the future of the show was discussed 7 years ago...





יום ראשון, 18 ביוני 2017

על Last of the wild.... דוגמא למפגש מוזיקלי מקצוות-הגלובוס

לפעמים נתקע לך לחן בראש.... ואתה מקשיב לו וגם משתף אחרים (שנתפשים או לא)



ואחרי זה אתה מגלה שלא רק לך הוא נתקע....
שיש אחרים שהתלהבו ממנו מספיק כדי לבצע אותו מחדש בדרכם שלהם...


נדמה לי שגם מתנגדי הגלובליזציה הכי גדולים לא יוכלו להכחיש את ההשפעות החיוביות
של מפגשים מוזיקליים מקצוות-הגלובוס... 

יום חמישי, 4 במאי 2017

The Big Bang Theory discrepancies - the sitcom's, not the other big bang

Are you a fan of the big bang theory sitcom?
How big a fan ? enough be interested in a comic-con panel ?

then maybe you will also be interested to read about the discrepancies I have been spotting in this show over the years.... spoiler alert: if you didn't watch the whole series till the relevant chapter, you will encounter spoilers!

Let us begin with a small bit:
A series-long issue that just doesn't stand to reason. How can penny afford living alone, while Leonard and Sheldon have to be roommates ? they live in the same building!
(think of the number of rooms + and recall that chapter when Sheldon tells Leonard "frankly, if i could afford the rent, i would throw you out" (it was season 1, episode 7; from now episodes shall be shortened to s for season, e for episode, combined with numbers making the format sXXeYY, and shortening that footnote into s01e07).

Before moving into a season-by-season detail, let us set some ground rules. We will only be judgmental to issues not holding together since season 3. Seasons 1&2 are not judged, because things were still finding themselves. Even basics, as since when did Sheldon and Leonard start living together changed between seasons 1 & 3; on s01e07, Sheldon tells Leonard that ever since they moved into the apartment, he watched Dr. Who on saturday morning; But on s03e22, we are told that Leonard moved into an apartment Sheldon was already living in. Not convinced? Consider Sheldon -
  • He was not always as arrogant; 
  • the roommate agreement did not manifest itself; 
  • Sheldon was actually noticing girls (Consider s01e07 for example. Remember Sheldon complaining that it cannot be that someone can be so pretty and good at video games as penny was in that episode? )
  • Sheldon did not insist on no-one sitting at his place (Compare s02e02 to s01e07 to see the inconsistent evolution of this concept) 
(for those who insisted, see the addendum-post: seasons 1&2 discrepancies)

Now, let us begin with the season-by-season discrepancy list:
  1. s03e03: Sheldon states - "Penny, while I subscribe to the many worlds theory which posits the existence of an infinite number of Sheldons in an infinite number of universes, I assure you that in none of them am I dancing." But this stands in contradiction to s04.e21 where sheldon tells Penny, Bernadette and Amy:"for the record, I’m an excellent dancer. Proficient in the rumba, waltz and cha-cha. " wonders "I don’t see why that’s surprising. I excel at so many things. You’ve had my sourdough bread." and explains that he took dance lessons "Against my will. In the South, pre-adolescent children are forced through a process called cotillion, which indoctrinates them with all the social graces and dance skills needed to function in 18th century Vienna."
  2. s03.e09: Penny says she told Bernadette some bad things about Howard, and yet, on s04e04 it turns out she never told her the real sassy bits...
  3. s03. e18: Sheldon the germophobe drinks alcohol out of glasses of other people, who have already drunk a little from them !!!
  4. s04.e10: Bernadette says that Howard gives her jewlery after every time they dine with his mother; and yet, on s04.e23 Bernadette and Howard's mom eat together for the first time, to get to know each other following the engagement.
  5. s04.e14: Howard says about Sheldon's disappointed response to students disliking his teaching style, "i think that is what Darth Vader said before he started building the death star", only Darth Vader never built the death star and any self-respecting geek show know that.
  6. s04e17: Sheldon tries ordering pizza on thursday night from a place called "Luigi", in a process which seems like a first-time order. but on s04e21 , on pizza night, it is declared that originally they ordered pizza from Franconi, according to the roommates agreement, and after he went out of business they switched to Grazziano (which is revealed to be against the rules, as Priya tells the guys)
  7. s04e21: Penny asks Sheldon if he had ever kissed a girl. He replies "Other than my mother, my sister and my mee-maw, no. But in the interest of full disclosure, I was once on a bus and had to give mouth-to-mouth resuscitation to an elderly nun who passed out from heat exhaustion. Every year I get a Christmas card from her, signed with far too many X’s and O’s."
    but on s03e10 Leonard's mother kissed Sheldon (and afterwards said she'd rather have the busboy).
  8. s04.e22 Priya and Leonard talk about a summer trip to India; s04.e24 Priya plans to get back to india and does not tell Leonard who accidentally hears about it when she and her parents video-chat.
  9. s04.e24 Priya says she can't believe she wears her brother's Halloween costume. Leonard says he can't believe she thinks he wears it only on Halloween. but on s04e18 Priya talked of the outfit with knowledge, as a great source of pain to the family... (and also on s04.e23 talked with penny about the days in which raj was in a group of friends which dressed like the power rangers - so why all of a sudden this ignorance regarding his costume habits?)
  10. s05e12: Howard tells Bernadette he started doing magic when he was a teenager. whereas in s06e07 (the "The Habitation Configuration" when Howard is actually moving out) Howard says he tried cheering his mom up after his father left (he was only 11 then).
  11. s05e12: Bernadette says she is not good with kids and hates kids cause her mom worked full time and she had to watch younger brothers and sisters. whereas in s03e14 she said her mother had an illegal daycare and therefore she "knows how to deal with stubborn children" (having performed the magic of being able to send sleepless Sheldon to bed).
  12. s05e15: Sheldon and Leonard stop being companions following Leonard's choice to go home after a white night at work, instead of remaining all day, to take Sheldon to the dentist in the afternoon. Sheldon arrives late to the apartment has dinner with everyone, and the following day is visiting Stuart's shop, seeking a ride to the dentist. talk about an editing blunder.
  13. s05e05: Howard tells his gf that he wants to take a one man submarine to explore the depths of the ocean but at s04e04 he said that having taken a scuba diving course he found out he is terrified by the ocean....(we could mention Bernadette's telling how howard got sea sick on pirates of the Caribbean.... ); one should say that this particular discrepancy might be solved/explained by referring to Howard's words as daydreaming/bragging... 
  14. s05.e17 Kripke and Sheldon are left at the restroom after president Siebert left. Kripke takes the urinal to the right and starts when Sheldon tells him "you are in my spot", but in s02e15 Sheldon agreed with Beverley (Leonard's mom) that "In bladder voiding, as in real estate, it’s location, location, location." . Although not decisive, it is implied that Sheldon agrees that the central urinal is the right choice , just like Leonard's mother prefers it (yes, it could be that he agrees to the principle of "the right urinal" but has other preferences. Have you known Sheldon so far to be the one who respects other people's preferences and choices when he has formed an opinion ?)
  15. s05e15: During another of the lapses in friendship (this time because of one night drill too many), Sheldon tries to interest the other friends in driving him around and mentions, among other transport needs, that he needs to be taken to Supercuts. but in s05e18 he tells Amy that he tried Supercuts and discovered that "They do men’s and women’s hair in the same room at the same time. It’s like Sodom and Gomorrah with mousse."
  16. s05e21: a critique's voice: no bachelorette party? REALLY? ?!? do us a chauvinist favor. We expect better from the characters of Amy and Penny. 
  17. s05e24: Penny knows people who were married in Vegas and suggests the option to Howard and Bernadette but in s07e09 she recalls her lovely thanksgiving day with Zack in Vegas when they did one of those fake weddings?
  18. s06e04: Sheldon can't swim because he has a higher than average body density... but in s02e13 it is mentioned that he has learned swimming by reading a "teach yourself to swim guide" and therefore does not need to attempt it in real life. Is it personal growth ? something that he discovered in the out-of-screen events taking place between the seasons ? or a plain discrepancy?
  19. s06.e04: Amy states that she finds the idea of dressing in matching costumes for a costumes party is one of the opportunities of proving your boyfriend is not imaginary and appears to have been looking forward to such an event. But in s04.e11 (in the dialogue where penny is persuaded to wear wonder woman's costume for the new year eve competition in the comics store)  Sheldon states that Amy is not as free spirited as him, and does not believe in wearing costumes.  
  20. s06e08: Sheldon describes Leonard as a good sleeper. A real catch compared to a guy who snores. And yet, on s08e09 he describes Leonard as snoring since he had met him....
  21. s06e09: Amy says that the battle over the parking spot between Howard and Sheldon couldn't be avoided because of them being two testosterone-fueled alpha males. But in s06e06 she got excited with Sheldon's potential victory over Steven Hawking (which never happened) because she thought it might give him a testosterone level...
  22. s06e11: We see the guys play D&D. they get to a room with a chest,try to open it, and then the walls start closing in, and only Sheldon's singing of Good King Wenceslas stops the walls. The scene is cut mid-song to another scene with the girls, and returns to Sheldon finishing his song. But then the D&D game continues with Leonard saying "you leave the room and find yourself in front of a melting snowman." What happened to the chest? why do they leave the room upon the Dungeon Master's order and not upon their own choice?  Horrible D&D continuity.
  23. s06.e20: Leonard says his mother would be proud if he got tenure at cal-tech, but at s02e15 his mother said about achievements of related persons "it her achievement, not mine, why should i be proud?" ... He should have known better...
    This discrepancy occurs again at s08e23. Then, she is proud of another son (arguing before the supreme court). Why this is worthy, but her daughter's scientific achievement wasn't ? (the daughter grew a human pancreas in a gibbon, for god's sake, but all Beverly had to say back then was "it's her achievement, not mine, why should i be proud?"
    And yet, about the re-occurrence, one might claim it is personal-growth for Beverley... 
  24. s07e05: Sheldon says he always interpreted "don't defecate where you eat" literally and that is why he never did that in any restaurant he ate, but he has been known to -
    1) speak about location location location to Leonard's mother (but he might be referring to peeing);
    2) go to the restroom in s05e04 (the D&D style dice rolling, decision making protocol) (but once again, it might be for peeing);
    3) has a very specific restroom schedule Leonard describes in s06e08 (the wormhole generator hoax chapter).
    but the decisive discrepancy argument: let us not forget the 1 hour it took Sheldon on s05e16, because of the time that it takes him in a new place.... 
  25. s07e15: Penny responds to Leonard's suggestion that they have sex on Sheldon's spot (Valentine's day and Sheldon and Amy are away), with "that is the least sexy thing anyone has ever said to me", but on s03e04, she suggested that they make out on Sheldon's spot... (is it a true discrepancy, or has penny embraced Sheldon's code?)
  26. s07e15: Leonard and Penny have been for a while in Leonard's room for Valentine's day sex. Later they argue  whether 9 minutes is a while, or 30 minutes is a while (the sex took the shorter time). but in s04e23 Leonard described himself as king of foreplay (and this was verified by Penny telling Priya he tries so hard, she actually fell asleep during foreplay).
  27. s08e05: the girls go to Vegas after checking about flights, but in s06e23 Amy was put on the no flights list.
  28. s08e08: Leonard tells Penny she would never had hit on him in prom because it was before his growth spurt.... but in s01e09 he told her his last growth spurt was in the eighth grade!
  29. s0820: Leonard suddenly has no money ? living a prudent life (with the exception of spending money on toys) for 8 consecutive seasons? living with a roommate at age 30 ? considering all the money Shledon has been keeping ? yes, we all know this was a premise of the pilot chapter, but that was 8 seasons ago, and since s01e01, the premise was that our nerdy heroes are doing quite well. And btw, Leonard could earn half of what penny does without being poor.
  30. s08e24: Leonard have not told Penny about making out with someone during his s07e01 north sea expedition? really ?!? that is so out of his character. totally un-Leonard not to torture himself with it during s07 and come out with the truth after 3 episodes... completely out of character. horrible scripting move, which stands in line with some other season 8 blunders.
    But wait. This could be considered as a wider discrepancy by the more critical. They would claim it is also an out-of-character moment for Penny. Remember Penny at s05e22? she was so confident that she has nothing to worry about Leonard going to Howard's bachelor party (sleazy Howard Wolowitz!) and she gets worried ? (But the more lenient would suggest that now that Penny has lowered her defenses, she is worried about Leonard; It might also be that having seen other women interested in Leonard (remember Alex?) she knows it is not far fetched as she used to think. It might also be that with her self esteem gone low she doesn't evaluate Leonard's devotion to her as in the past. And one last option - she might know that he is no longer his former shyness ....) 
  31. s09e02 Howard knows how much marriage Counseling costs. Raj is surprised. But in s08e09 it was told that Raj and Howard went to couple's counseling together (back then, btw, Bernadette did not know about it at all.
  32. s09e3: Penny is sure that deceased Moondance, penny's late hog, was buried in the yard and does not agree to the idea that her family would eat a beloved pet. But on s07e22 (Arthur's funeral) she told about her former experience with death, when her former pet pig died. "I had a pet pig when I was a kid. I mean, when he died, we didn't have a funeral, we had a barbecue." 
  33. s09e09: what happened to the tradition of a thanksgiving meal Sheldon was nagging about so much in s07e09?
  34. s09e09: Penny not remembering Leonard's birthday is totally out of character. Is it logical that the girl who kept every nostalgic item of their relationship (s07e06) and who especially arranged a surprise party back when her acquaintance with Howard was in early infancy (s01e16) because he never had birthday parties celebrated before will forget her spouses birthday?
  35. s09e09: Penny telling Sheldon she never remained a friend with any of her ex-boyfriends, while we all remember season 4 and the relevant bits from 3 & 5 .... (also her wedding vows, when she told leonard he is her best friend).
  36. s09e15: Rajesh asks the friends (who mock him), if any of them ever broke up a relationship with anyone, and they remain speechless, and no one mentions:
    1) leonard breaking up with dr. Stephanie Barnett (s02e10);
    2) sheldon breaking up with the Ramona Lewitzki (s02e06);
    3) leonard breaking up with Pryia (s05e07).
  37. s09e20: playing the drinking game "never have i ever", Sheldon tells he has been arrested but only for j-walking. But what about that time on s02e16 when Sheldon insisted on not paying a traffic ticket, insulted a judge and was arrested? (Penny was there! and yet, neither Sheldon nor Penny remember it....)
  38. s10e04: Leonard, troubled by the forming friendship  between Penny and his mother, tells her he married her to hurt his mother, which might be nice as a joke for the chapter, but contradicts Leonard's anxious will to please his mother, and his fear from his mother's opinion about Penny as a girlfriend, back in s03e11. 
  39. s10e05: Amy has difficulties adjusting to Sheldon's bathroom schedule, and yet, on s07e16 she responded to Sheldon's telling of the difficulties he had in training Leonard to a bathroom schedule with empathy to Shledon's difficulties (she described Leonard's prior bathroom habits with the sentence - "like a dog boy"). One would expect that she too, would have strict habits, similar to Sheldon's. 
  40. s10e10: Sheldon tells Leonard he never beat him in 3d chess (as an excuse why Sheldon should take the set to his apartment as the roommates finally separate). But on s05e23, Leonard was winning,before the two stopped the game to "bellyaching about their ol’ ladies".
  41. s11e08: Sheldon (while arguing with Amy about his adison/tesla behaviour regarding the army project) states that he does not know any neurologist name other than amy.... but we all remember the Babinski defecates Maxwell argument from s04e03(Joseph Babinski is a french neurologist best known for the decription of the babinski sign, a reflex elicited when the sole of the foot is stimulated with a blunt instrumen). 
Wow.... that was a rather long list of discrepancies for a series that deals with science, wouldn't you say?

Have any other discrepancy you wish to add? Don't agree with an item? feel free to talk back or write to me.

Addendum 1: How did Leonard get Penny ? 
Before we depart, let us discuss another annoying issue. Maybe not exactly a discrepancy, but definitely a bad call by the script writers.
In season 8 there is this notion that Leonard got Penny by begging (s08e07, with Dr. Lorvis)/
by making her feel sorry for himself (leonard saying so himself on s08e19). But this is completely
inconsistent with the way the series played out (Penny realizing by s04's end that Leonard
is a great guy and she messed up with him; Leonard growing confident enough to suggest
they start going together again during s05e13). Whatever the others might be saying to
break Leonard's balls, there is just no way in the world that he will say it about himself.
he knows he earned it.

Addendum 2: Sheldon's driving 
Sheldon's driving has knowing some highs and lows. Not all consistent with each other...

  • s02e05: Sheldon is forced by the others (uncharacteristically) to get a driving learner's permit. But he is unable to learn to drive, displaying horrible skills on a simulator. 
  • s03e08: Sheldon drives Penny to the hospital as she had dislocated her shoulder and no one else can help. 
  • s03e22: Sheldon says that he can drive but prefers not to.
  • s08e12: Sheldon tells Leonard that Amy has taught him how to drive. That he avoids
    it because he is afraid and sometimes gets the pedals mixed up. But more impoprtantly,
    driving Sheldon to work is one of the things that give purpose to Leonard's life.
  • s10e16: Sheldon tells Amy he got his driver's license two years ago, but that he lets her chauffeur him to let her feel important.
  • s11e04: Sheldon tells Howard he has a license for 3 years, but that -
     1) he barely passed the test
     2) the only time he drove, he made a u turn, got dizzy, threw up and walked home.
    at the end of that chapter, btw, Sheldon, getting confident as a driver thanks to Howard's fatherly style of guiding him,  gets stopped by a cop for speeding. Sheldon hands the cop his license and tells him that he won't be needing it anymore. 

Addendum 3: Some useful resources


[update: 16/07/2017:  the addendum-post: seasons 1&2 discrepancies has been published!]
[updated: 31/10/2017; updated addendum 2]
[updated: 1/12/2017; added item 42 on the list of discrepancies]

יום שני, 24 באפריל 2017

בין טרור ושואה

אחד הדיונים ההיסטוריים הקשים והמרים יותר בנוגע לשואה הוא אותו נסיון להבין את הגורמים לה. את שורשיה. את התהליכים שאפשרו אותה והביאו אליה. באסכולה הזו ניתן למצוא פער בולט בין אלה הסבורים ששואת יהדות אירופה וצפון אפריקה היא אירוע סינגולרי לבין אלה הסבורים כי היא אחד מכמה וכמה אירועי השמדת-עם שאירעו לה, לאנושות, עם הזמן (או שיותר נכון, שבוצעו על ידי חלקים מהאנושות כלפי חלקים אחרים... אחרי הכל, כולנו בני-אדם, לא?) 

מבין הגורמים השונים והמשונים המוזכרים מעת לעת, רציתי להזכיר היום את ה-Schrecklichkeit, הטרור או ההפחדה, אותה מדיניות צבאית שננקטה בידי גרמניה בראשית מלחמה העולם הראשונה (הראשונה, כן? לא השניה). במסגרת אותה מדיניות, נקט הצבא הגרמני במה שתאורטיקנים צבאיים יכנו יד קשה ומשפטנים מודרניים יכנו פשעי-מלחמה כלפי האוכלוסיה האזרחים בשטחים שנכבשו על ידי צבא גרמניה, בעיקר בבלגיה. 

ההגיון הצבאי מאחורי אותה מדיניות?  כתגובה מרתיעה כלפי התנגדות אזרחית, לוחמת גרילה,ופעילות מחתרתית אחרת - לגבי כולן יש כיום מחלוקת בין היסטוריונים בנוגע להיקף ולמידת קיומם בראשית המלחמה. מה שברור הוא שבאיזורים שונים בבלגיה בהם כבר שלט הצבא הגרמני, נקטו הכוחות הגרמניים פעולות כוחניות מאוד כלפי אוכלוסיה אזרחית ובהן הוצאה להורג של מאות אזרחים (ביניהם כמרים שנחשדו בהסתת האוכלוסיה האזרחית להתנגדות) ושריפת והריסת מבנים לא מעטים (שהגיעו לשיא בעיר לוון; שריפת הספריה שלה זעזעה את העולם התמים של 1914). הכל מתוך הנחה שהאלימות הזו תרתיע את הבלגים ותביא אותם לכניעה ולשיתוף פעולה מלאים.

המניע הרגשי מאחורי אותה מדיניות? הצבא הגרמני לא ציפה להתעכב רבות בתנועה שלו דרך בלגיה אל עבר צרפת. ההתנגדות הבלגית הפתיעה את הפיקוד הגרמני, והחשש מהשלכות העיכוב בשילוב הצית את הבעירה הרגשית שהניעה את מדיניות ה-Schrecklichkeit. לפחות זה התירוץ המקובל. תסכול, אתם יודעים, הוא מנוע חזק מאוד להתנהגות לא נורמטיבית. 

אלא שאותה התנהלות נראתה לאחר מכן באיזורים אחרים שנשלטו על ידי הצבא הגרמני במלחמת העולם הראשונה. (הראשונה, כן? אנחנו עדיין מדברים על 1914-1918). גם בצרפת, בפולין וברוסיה. הרגלים רעים, אתם יודעים, נרכשים מהר ואחר-כך קשה להיפטר מהם. 

אבל מה המכנה המשותף לטרור הזה ולשואה 'שלנו' ? האומנם זו התרגלות לאלימות ? אפשר לטעון גם את הטענה הזו, אבל הטענה שלי היא אחרת וקשורה יותר לתודעה. ה-Schrecklichkeit הוא תוצר של תודעה המביטה על המציאות ורואה בבני-אדם רגילים דבר אחר לגמרי. היא מייחסת פוטנציאל צבאי וסכנה למי שאיננו מסכן אותך. המבט הזה, שמזהה איום בדברים תמימים לגמרי, הוא המקביל לדריכת הנשק. הדריכה של התודעה לפעולה. 

לאחר מכן, כשנוצרת מציאות שבה מתנהלת מלחמה לחיים ולמוות, קל מאוד להוציא אל הפועל כל מעשה של אלימות כלפי כל מי שמסכן אותך. השאלה האם הוא מסכן אותך במציאות איננה רלוונטית עוד. כל מה שרלוונטי קורה בתוך הראש שלך.